A Little Bit of Italy in Your Own Back Yard!


3273 Main Street - Mexico, New York



• Tue - Fri: 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
• Sat - Sun: 2:00 pm - 10:00 pm
• Closed Mondays
Stefano's is known for more than just crispy, delicious pizza. Every week, Stefano's offers special dishes to feature for our menu. Our Specials are sure to satisfy your taste buds as well as your wallet.

What's Cooking Today

We Deliver!

Just call us at 315.963.8888 and we will deliver your order hot and fresh!
We deliver to Mexico, New Haven, Parish, Palermo and all the surrounding camp grounds...

Also if your order is above $150.00 we will deliver almost anywhere! We also cater lunches and parties
(must meet minimum order amount) outside of that area
including, Oswego, Parish and Syracuse!

Our Big Announcement!

We are excited to announce that we have moved into our new and bigger location at the former Hart & Stone building.

We now offer an expanded menu and a full service dining room at night with beer and wine in a casual relaxed atmosphere.

Pizza Specials

Large Cheese Pizza & 30 Wings: $29.95
Large Cheese Pizza, 20 Wings & Large Antipasto:
24 Cut Pizza & 50 Wings: 

Small Cheese Pizza & 10 Wings:


Special Delivery...

Stefano's is always doing something special....specials on food items, discount programs, promotions, and more. 

Sign up for our "Special Delivery Email" to receive our latest news and information.

Your Stories...

We love to share photos and stories of people enjoying themselves at our restaurants. Send us your “Stefano’s Experience”!

Gift Cards...

Send your digital photos and stories to:


Stefano's gift cards make the perfect gift! Available in any amount, they are sure to being a smile to anyone for any special event. Stop-in and ask about our Gift Cards.

Buy a Large Pizza from Stefano's Pizzeria and Receive a "Pizza Card". Return 10 cards and Receive One Large Plain Pizza FREE!

Get Free Pizza!

Customers are Saying......

A "Taste" of  What Our

Stefano and Alessandra enjoying our cuisine!

Our Three Locations...

258 State Street

Carthage, New York


3852 Rt. 13

Pulaski, New York


3273 Main Street

Mexico, New York


"I got a smiley face on my pizza box....what a nice touch! Keep up the great work!" - Brad G.